Expert Guide

Deputy Alternatives 2026: Shift Scheduling Apps Priced for 25 Staff

Seven shift scheduling and time clock apps compared on what a 25-person hourly team pays each month, which features sit behind the paid tier, and how each one bills.

Product links may be affiliate links. How we rate 7 tools compared
TL;DR

Homebase is the best Deputy alternative for a single-location team of about 25 hourly staff in 2026: its Essentials plan costs $30 a month per location with unlimited employees, against $137.50 a month for 25 users on Deputy Lite billed monthly. Connecteam runs time clock and scheduling for the first 30 users at $35 a month, and Sling schedules up to 30 users on a free plan.

Pick When I Work for auto-scheduling at $2.50 per user, Camelo for a flat $29 a month for the first 30 members, ZoomShift for a free plan up to 20 users, and Buddy Punch when time tracking matters more than price. Prices were read on each vendor's pricing page on November 4, 2026.

Key facts7 tools compared: Homebase, Connecteam, Sling, When I Work, Camelo, ZoomShift, Buddy Punch
  • Updated: November 19, 2026
  • Top pick: Homebase (best for: Single-location restaurants and shops with 11 to 50 hourly staff who want one flat monthly price)
  • Top pick price as of November 19, 2026: Homebase: Free plan · Essentials $30/mo · Plus $70/mo · All-in-One $120/mo
  • 7 tools compared: Homebase, Connecteam, Sling, When I Work, Camelo, ZoomShift, Buddy Punch
  • Connecteam (best for: Field and deskless teams that want time clock, scheduling, forms and tasks in one app): Free plan · Operations Hub Basic $29/mo on the annual plan · Operations Hub Advanced $49/mo on the annual plan ·…
  • Sling (best for: Teams of up to 30 that need a schedule and messaging and can track hours elsewhere): Free plan · Premium $2/mo per user · Business $4/mo per user
  • When I Work (best for: Teams that want auto scheduling and forecast tools at the lowest per-user rate): Essentials $2.50/mo per user · Pro $5/mo per user · Premium $8/mo per user

Deputy is a capable scheduler, but its per-user price is what pushes small hourly teams to look around. Its pricing page lists Lite at $5.50 per user a month on monthly billing (less on annual), Core at $6.50 or $7.25 and Pro at $9 or $10, with a $30 minimum monthly spend on monthly plans since September 1, 2025. At 25 staff, that puts the cheapest Deputy plan near $1,650 a year on monthly billing, by our arithmetic.

The billing rules matter as much as the rate. Deputy charges a new user the full month even if they join in its last week, and an annual plan cannot be switched or reduced in headcount, with no refund on early cancellation. HRpresso data: Toolradar, the software directory Dupple runs, lists Deputy as an alternative to 18 other tools, joint #7 of 78 in its payroll category, as of November 2026 on its Deputy profile. Most of that crowd charges per user too, which is why the picks below are ranked on what 25 people cost, not on the headline rate.

Top Picks

Based on features, real-world fit, and value for money.

#1 Top pick

Homebase

Scheduling, time tracking and team messaging priced per location with unlimited employees, plus optional payroll and hiring.

Pricing

Free plan · Essentials $30/mo · Plus $70/mo · All-in-One $120/moChecked Nov 15, 2026 on Toolradar

Best for

Single-location restaurants and shops with 11 to 50 hourly staff who want one flat monthly price.

#2

Connecteam

An all-in-one app for deskless teams, sold as Operations, Communications and HR hubs, each priced for the first 30 users.

Pricing

Free plan · Operations Hub Basic $29/mo on the annual plan · Operations Hub Advanced $49/mo on the annual plan · Operations Hub Expert $99/mo on the annual plan · custom-priced plans tooChecked Nov 9, 2026 on Toolradar

Best for

Field and deskless teams that want time clock, scheduling, forms and tasks in one app.

#3

Sling

A scheduling app, now Sling by Toast, with a free plan for up to 30 users and paid tiers for time tracking and labor costs.

Pricing

Free plan · Premium $2/mo per user · Business $4/mo per userChecked Nov 16, 2026 on Toolradar

Best for

Teams of up to 30 that need a schedule and messaging and can track hours elsewhere.

Deputy Alternatives 2026: Shift Scheduling Apps Priced for 25 Staff: 7 tools compared, updated Nov 2026
ToolPricingBest for
HomebaseFree plan · Essentials $30/mo · Plus $70/mo · All-in-One $120/moSingle-location restaurants and shops with 11 to 50 hourly staff who want one flat monthly price.
ConnecteamFree plan · Operations Hub Basic $29/mo on the annual plan · Operations Hub Advanced $49/mo on the annual plan ·…Field and deskless teams that want time clock, scheduling, forms and tasks in one app.
SlingFree plan · Premium $2/mo per user · Business $4/mo per userTeams of up to 30 that need a schedule and messaging and can track hours elsewhere.
When I WorkEssentials $2.50/mo per user · Pro $5/mo per user · Premium $8/mo per userTeams that want auto scheduling and forecast tools at the lowest per-user rate.
CameloFree up to 10 members; Pro $29/mo for the first 30 members; Premium $99/mo; annual billing saves 17%Growing teams of 11 to 30 who want advanced scheduling and time tracking for one flat fee.
ZoomShiftFree plan · Starter $2/mo per user on the annual plan · Premium $4/mo per user on the annual planSmall teams that want a free schedule today and a cheap per-user time clock later.
Buddy PunchPro $7.99/user/mo monthly or $6.99 annually, plus $19 base fee; scheduling included on ProBusinesses where accurate punches and break compliance matter more than the lowest price.

Pricing read from each vendor's own pricing page, checked Nov 2026. 1 of 7 publishes prices for some plans and quotes the rest.

Lowest published monthly price by toolBar chart of the lowest monthly price each vendor publishes; the same figures are in the comparison table above.Lowest published monthly priceHomebaseFreeConnecteamFreeSlingFreeCamelo$29ZoomShiftFreeBuddy Punch$7.99
Lowest monthly figure each vendor publishes, checked Nov 2026. A tilde marks a figure the vendor states approximately. Per-seat and usage charges can sit on top of it. 1 of 7 does not publish a comparable monthly price and is left out rather than estimated.
1 Homebase logo
Top Pick

Homebase

Scheduling, time tracking and team messaging priced per location with unlimited employees, plus optional payroll and hiring.

Pricing
Free plan · Essentials $30/mo · Plus $70/mo · All-in-One $120/moChecked Nov 15, 2026 on Toolradar

Best for: Single-location restaurants and shops with 11 to 50 hourly staff who want one flat monthly price.

Pros

  • Essentials covers unlimited employees at one location, so new hires do not raise the bill
  • Annual billing lowers Essentials to $24, Plus to $56 and All-in-One to $96 per location a month
  • Free 14-day trial of All-in-One, then a fall back to the free Basic plan if you do not pick one

Cons

  • Priced per location, so a five-site business pays five plan fees
  • Payroll is a separate add-on at $49 a month plus $6 per employee paid
2 Connecteam logo

Connecteam

An all-in-one app for deskless teams, sold as Operations, Communications and HR hubs, each priced for the first 30 users.

Pricing
Free plan · Operations Hub Basic $29/mo on the annual plan · Operations Hub Advanced $49/mo on the annual plan · Operations Hub Expert $99/mo on the annual plan · custom-priced plans tooChecked Nov 9, 2026 on Toolradar

Best for: Field and deskless teams that want time clock, scheduling, forms and tasks in one app.

Pros

  • Operations Basic covers GPS time clock, scheduling with open shifts and payroll integration
  • The Small Business plan gives all hubs and features free for up to 10 users
  • Yearly billing saves 18%, bringing Advanced to $49 a month for the first 30 users

Cons

  • Each hub is priced separately, so chat and HR tools add a second and third subscription
  • Above 30 users each extra person costs $1.0 a month on Basic and $3.0 on Advanced, billed monthly
3 Sling logo

Sling

A scheduling app, now Sling by Toast, with a free plan for up to 30 users and paid tiers for time tracking and labor costs.

Pricing
Free plan · Premium $2/mo per user · Business $4/mo per userChecked Nov 16, 2026 on Toolradar

Best for: Teams of up to 30 that need a schedule and messaging and can track hours elsewhere.

Pros

  • Shift scheduling, time-off requests, available shifts and private messaging are free for up to 30 users
  • Premium adds time tracking and labor cost tools for a small per-user fee, 15% less on annual billing
  • 15-day free trial of the paid plans

Cons

  • Time clock and labor cost tools need a paid plan, so the free tier is scheduling only
  • Business at $4 a user doubles the Premium rate for payroll reports and labor data
4 When I Work logo

When I Work

Employee scheduling with team messaging on every plan, auto scheduling from the entry tier and an optional time and attendance add-on.

Pricing
Essentials $2.50/mo per user · Pro $5/mo per user · Premium $8/mo per userChecked Nov 15, 2026 on Toolradar

Best for: Teams that want auto scheduling and forecast tools at the lowest per-user rate.

Pros

  • Essentials includes auto scheduling, multi-week schedules, forecast tools and multi-location scheduling
  • Pro adds scheduling rules, role permissions and labor sharing at twice the Essentials rate
  • Unlimited users on every plan, with monthly or annual billing

Cons

  • Time tracking and attendance is a separate add-on on each plan
  • API keys, webhooks and SSO need Premium at $8 a user
5 Camelo logo

Camelo

A scheduling, time tracking and team communication app whose paid plans cover 30 members for a single monthly price.

Pricing
Free up to 10 members; Pro $29/mo for the first 30 members; Premium $99/mo; annual billing saves 17%

Best for: Growing teams of 11 to 30 who want advanced scheduling and time tracking for one flat fee.

Pros

  • Pro covers unlimited schedules plus advanced scheduling and time tracking for the first 30 members
  • Free plan includes almost all Pro features for up to 10 members
  • 14-day free trial of all features and 24/7 support

Cons

  • Each member past 30 adds $3.5 a month on Pro and $4.5 on Premium
  • Payroll integration, labor forecasting and overtime policies need Premium at $99 a month
6 ZoomShift logo

ZoomShift

Employee scheduling and time clock software with a free tier for small teams and per-user paid plans.

Pricing
Free plan · Starter $2/mo per user on the annual plan · Premium $4/mo per user on the annual planChecked Nov 16, 2026 on Toolradar

Best for: Small teams that want a free schedule today and a cheap per-user time clock later.

Pros

  • Starter adds timesheets, time clock, PTO and break tracking with unlimited locations
  • Premium includes auto-scheduling, overtime warnings and a geofence time clock
  • No cancellation fee or minimum contract

Cons

  • The free plan covers one location and schedules only 2 weeks ahead
  • A 25-person team is above the free limit and pays per active member
7 Buddy Punch logo

Buddy Punch

Time tracking software with GPS, geofencing and kiosk punches, where the Pro plan includes the scheduling add-on.

Pricing
Pro $7.99/user/mo monthly or $6.99 annually, plus $19 base fee; scheduling included on Pro

Best for: Businesses where accurate punches and break compliance matter more than the lowest price.

Pros

  • Pro includes geofencing, QR code and kiosk punches, webcam photos and break compliance
  • Unlimited administrator users at no extra cost
  • API and MCP access on Pro for connecting other tools and AI assistants

Cons

  • At 25 staff Pro costs more than Deputy Lite once the $19 base fee is added
  • Scheduling is an add-on on Starter and is included only from Pro

What it is

A Deputy alternative is shift scheduling and time clock software for hourly teams: build the weekly schedule, let staff swap or claim shifts on their phones, clock in and out, and export approved hours to payroll. Restaurants, retail stores, clinics and service crews use these tools in place of a spreadsheet and a group chat.

Pricing follows three models, and the model decides the bill at 25 staff. Per-user plans (Deputy, When I Work, ZoomShift, Buddy Punch) grow with every hire. Flat per-location plans (Homebase) stay the same as headcount rises. Bundled seat blocks (Connecteam, Camelo) charge one price for the first 30 users and a small fee per extra person.

Why it matters

For 25 staff at one location, the monthly bill ranges from $0 to $218.75. On our arithmetic from each vendor's printed monthly-billing prices, the entry plan with scheduling and a time clock is cheapest on Camelo Pro and Homebase Essentials, both under a third of Deputy's price. Connecteam's Operations Basic comes next, then Sling Premium at $50, ZoomShift Starter at $62.50, Deputy Lite, and Buddy Punch Pro at $218.75 once its base fee is added. Sling's free plan covers scheduling alone for the same team.

Hiring changes the order. A per-user plan adds cost with every new hire, so a team growing from 25 to 40 adds $82.50 a month on Deputy Lite, while Homebase Essentials stays at the same flat fee for unlimited employees. The catch runs the other way for a chain: Homebase charges per location, so five small sites pay five times, where a per-user plan only counts heads.

Key features to look for

Pricing model
Per user (Deputy, When I Work, ZoomShift, Buddy Punch), flat per location (Homebase) or a block of 30 users (Connecteam, Camelo). For a stable 25-person team at one site, flat models cost the least.
Free plan limits
Sling schedules up to 30 users free, ZoomShift up to 20, and Homebase, Connecteam and Camelo up to 10. Deputy offers a free trial but no free plan.
Auto-scheduling and forecasting
Deputy puts auto-scheduling and demand forecasting in Core. When I Work includes auto scheduling and forecast tools from Essentials, and ZoomShift reserves auto-scheduling for Premium.
Time clock controls
Buddy Punch Pro adds geofencing, QR punches, kiosk mode and webcam photos. Deputy saves biometric clocking for Core, and ZoomShift's geofence time clock sits in Premium.
Payroll
Homebase sells payroll as an add-on with a monthly base fee plus a per-employee charge. Deputy's US payroll runs through Paycor on annual Core and Pro plans, and Camelo's payroll integration needs Premium.

Pricing

Prices were read on each vendor's own pricing page on November 4, 2026: Deputy, Homebase, Connecteam, Sling, When I Work, Camelo, ZoomShift and Buddy Punch. When I Work shows some visitors a different plan lineup; the prices here are its standard plans.

Scenario method: 25 active hourly employees, one location, monthly billing, the cheapest plan that includes both scheduling and a time clock (Sling's free plan is scheduling only). Per-user plans are 25 times the printed rate; flat plans are the printed fee. Over twelve months that comes to $348 on Camelo, $360 on Homebase, $420 on Connecteam, $600 on Sling Premium, $750 on ZoomShift Starter, $1,650 on Deputy Lite and $2,625 on Buddy Punch Pro. When I Work's $750 a year on Essentials covers scheduling only, since its time and attendance add-on is priced separately. All figures are our arithmetic.

Watch out: Deputy's annual plan bills the whole year up front, and extra users added mid-year are charged at the monthly rate. Its add-ons run $1.50 to $2 per user a month each, and Deputy Payroll by Paycor starts at $8 per user plus a $49 monthly base fee, varying by business size. Homebase's offer of six free months of Plus is tied to activating its payroll and is labeled a limited-time offer.

Methodology: we listed the scheduling apps a Deputy customer with roughly 25 hourly staff is most likely to weigh, read each vendor's pricing page and FAQ for prices, limits and billing rules, and ranked them on the 25-staff monthly cost, the features included at that price and how the bill grows with headcount. We have not run these apps with a live team; every price comes from the vendor's own page, and the Toolradar figures come from our catalog.

PlanPriceBest for
Deputy Lite$5.50/user/mo monthly ($5 annual)Basic scheduling, timesheets and time clocking, shift swaps, leave management
Deputy Core$7.25/user/mo monthly ($6.50 annual)Auto-scheduling, demand forecasting, biometric clocking, wage budgets
Deputy Pro$10/user/mo monthly ($9 annual)SSO, location hierarchies, sandbox, 24/7 live chat, analytics and messaging add-ons
Homebase BasicFree1 location, up to 10 employees, basic scheduling and time tracking
Homebase Essentials$30/location/mo ($24 annual)Unlimited employees at one location
Homebase Plus$70/location/mo ($56 annual)Everything in Essentials plus more labor and team tools
Connecteam Operations Basic$35/mo first 30 users ($29 yearly)GPS time clock, scheduling with open shifts, payroll integration
Connecteam Operations Advanced$59/mo first 30 users ($49 yearly)Advanced filters, bulk actions and faster workflows
Sling FreeFreeScheduling, time-off requests and messaging for up to 30 users
Sling Premium$2/user/mo ($1.70 annual)Adds time tracking and labor cost tools
When I Work Essentials$2.50/user/moAuto scheduling, forecast tools, team messaging, unlimited users
When I Work Pro$5/user/moScheduling rules, role permissions, labor sharing, custom reports
Camelo Pro$29/mo first 30 membersUnlimited schedules, advanced scheduling and time tracking
Camelo Premium$99/mo first 30 membersPayroll integration, labor forecasting, overtime and time off policies
ZoomShift Starter$2.50/user/mo ($2 annual)Timesheets, time clock, PTO and breaks tracking, unlimited locations
ZoomShift Premium$5/user/mo ($4 annual)Auto-scheduling, overtime warnings, geofence time clock
Buddy Punch Pro$7.99/user/mo + $19 base ($6.99 annual)Scheduling included, geofencing, kiosk and QR punches, break compliance
Mistakes to avoid
×Comparing per-user rates against flat fees. When I Work's entry rate looks cheaper than Homebase's flat fee, but at 25 staff it is $62.50 a month for scheduling only.
×Signing an annual Deputy plan before headcount settles. Deputy does not let an annual customer lower the number of employees or change plan, and early cancellation brings no refund.
×Counting only the scheduling plan. Payroll and messaging add-ons can cost more than the scheduler: Homebase payroll for 25 people adds $199 a month on our arithmetic from its printed fees.
Expert tips
→Count active users, not total staff. ZoomShift bills per active team member, and Deputy charges a full month for anyone added or unarchived during it.
→Run the same week's schedule in two tools during their free trials; most of these apps give 14 or 15 days, enough for two pay-period cycles of a weekly rota.
→If you run several small sites, price per-user plans first. Homebase's flat fee wins at one location but multiplies with each address.

The bottom line

Homebase (Toolradar profile) is the first trial for a one-site team of about 25, and our Homebase vs Deputy comparison and Homebase review go deeper. Connecteam (Toolradar profile) suits field teams, as covered in Connecteam vs Deputy, and Sling (Toolradar profile) is the free option for scheduling alone, per our Sling review.

When I Work (Toolradar profile) wins on auto scheduling per dollar, see Deputy vs When I Work; ZoomShift (Toolradar profile), Camelo and Buddy Punch fill the gaps on free tiers, flat seats and punch accuracy. Before leaving, check Deputy pricing and our Deputy review; for wider lists see best free employee scheduling apps, Homebase alternatives and Toolradar's Deputy alternatives.

Cite this: HRpresso, "Deputy Alternatives 2026: Shift Scheduling Apps Priced for 25 Staff", November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

What are the best Deputy alternatives in 2026?

Homebase is the best Deputy alternative for a single-location team of about 25 hourly staff, because Essentials charges one flat monthly fee per location with unlimited employees. Connecteam ($35 a month for the first 30 users) and Sling (free scheduling for up to 30 users) follow, with When I Work, Camelo, ZoomShift and Buddy Punch for specific needs. Prices were read in November 2026.

How much does Deputy cost for 25 employees?

Deputy Lite costs $5.50 per user a month on monthly billing, so 25 employees pay $137.50 a month, about $1,650 a year by our arithmetic. Core at $7.25 per user brings that to $181.25 a month. Annual billing saves 10% but locks the plan and headcount for the year.

Is there a free alternative to Deputy?

Sling's free plan schedules up to 30 users with time-off requests and messaging, and ZoomShift is free for up to 20. Homebase, Connecteam and Camelo are free for up to 10. Deputy itself has a free trial but no free plan.

Which Deputy alternative has auto-scheduling?

When I Work includes auto scheduling and forecast tools from its entry Essentials plan, and ZoomShift includes it on Premium. On Deputy, auto-scheduling and demand forecasting start at Core.

Is Homebase cheaper than Deputy?

For one location, yes: Homebase Essentials is one flat monthly fee with unlimited employees, far below the $137.50 for 25 users on Deputy Lite. For a business with many small sites, Deputy's per-user pricing can cost less, because Homebase charges each location separately.

Does Deputy have a minimum spend?

Yes. Since September 1, 2025 Deputy's monthly Lite, Core and Pro plans carry a minimum spend of $30 a month per invoice, so a very small team still pays that floor. Annual plans are billed up front for the year.

Sources

Prices and plan details come from each vendor's own pricing page, re-checked by the Toolradar pricing tracker.

Related guides

Some offers on this page may be paid placements or contain affiliate links.

More HRpresso reviews

Buyer guides and software reviews, with prices read from each vendor's own pricing page.

Browse all reviews