Payroll4Free Review 2026
What the ad-supported free tier covers, every fee on Payroll4Free's own fee schedule, what a five-person and a twelve-person team really pay, and how OnPay, Square, Wave and Roll compare.
Payroll4Free is really free in 2026 only if you pay 9 or fewer people once a month and file your own payroll taxes. That core service costs $0, funded by ads in the software, though filled-in tax forms carry a small quarterly fee. Hand tax filing to Payroll4Free and add direct deposit through its bank, and a five-person team pays $500 a year on annual billing (our arithmetic).
Even at that price it undercuts full-service rivals: at list prices the same five people cost $780 a year on Square Payroll, $840 on Wave and $948 on OnPay. The trade is software you must download, ads on every payday screen, a fee for nearly every change staff make for you and a cash reserve if you use its direct deposit service.
Key factsBest for: Owners of very small teams, paid monthly in one state, who…
- Genuinely free payroll, paid for by in-app ads and a long fee schedule for anything beyond the basics.
- Free tier: Payroll processing, tax calculations, checks and own-bank direct deposit cost nothing for small teams paid once a month.
- Tax filing: Having Payroll4Free deposit and file your payroll taxes is a paid service, billed monthly or at a discount yearly.
- Full service, 5 people: Tax filing plus direct deposit through its bank comes to $500 a year on annual billing (our arithmetic).
- How it is funded: Advertisers pay to show ads inside the payroll software you log in to.
Pros
- Payroll runs, tax calculations, checks and own-bank direct deposit cost $0 for small teams.
- Full service for five people costs $500 a year on annual billing, below every rival here.
- Pays W-2 employees and 1099 contractors on the same payroll.
Cons
- The free limit reads 9 people on the homepage and 10 in the terms, and extra pay runs add fees.
- Direct deposit through its bank needs a reserve sized to your largest seven-day payroll.
Payroll4Free has offered free payroll since 2012, and the pitch on its homepage is blunt: no bills, ever. That is true for a narrow but real group of businesses, and the business model explains the limits: advertisers pay to place ads inside the software you open every payday, and paid add-ons cover the jobs that cost the company money.
Toolradar data: of the 78 payroll tools tracked on Toolradar's payroll statistics, the software directory we run, only 15% have a free plan, and the median entry paid plan is $25 a month (as of November 4, 2026). A free payroll tool is unusual, which is why the catches deserve a close read.
Below we cover what the free tier includes, every line on Payroll4Free's fee schedule that a small team is likely to hit, what three common setups cost per year, and how OnPay, Square Payroll, Wave and Roll by ADP price the same team. Every fee was read on the vendor's own pages on November 4, 2026.
What is Payroll4Free?
Payroll4Free is an online payroll system for small US employers. The free tier pays W-2 employees and 1099 contractors by paper check or by direct deposit from your own bank, calculates federal, state and local taxes, tracks vacation, sick and PTO accruals, and gives employees a portal for pay stubs and W-2s. Deductions such as 401(k) contributions and garnishments can be set up as custom pay items.
Access runs through software the company provides. Its terms name a Secure Business Browser, and its FAQ says a small browser extension must be downloaded, so this is not a log-in-from-any-browser tool like most rivals. Support is by phone and email.
How Payroll4Free works
You set up the company, employees and tax accounts with a guided wizard, enter hours or salaries each payday and post the payroll batch. On the free tier, paying taxes is your job: the system calculates what you owe and prepares the forms, and you make the deposits and filings yourself. Any missed deposit or late filing is your responsibility, not the software's.
Two paid services take work off your desk. The Payroll Tax Service deposits and files your payroll taxes, including year-end W-2s. The Direct Deposit Service moves pay through Payroll4Free's bank instead of yours, and it requires a reserve deposit equal to your largest expected seven-day direct deposit payroll, rounded up to the next $1,000, held for as long as you stay enrolled.
Timing is stricter than with app-first rivals. The terms ask for funds generally at least four business days before the pay date, and the reserve must be authorized at least 15 business days before your first direct deposit. Cancelling direct deposit takes effect only at month end, with 15 days' notice.
Payroll4Free key features
Payroll4Free pricing
Payroll4Free's core service is free, and everything else is listed on its fee schedule, last updated June 1, 2025 and read on November 4, 2026 together with the terms of service, the direct deposit terms and the FAQ. Monthly services are charged for any calendar month you are enrolled, even if you run no payroll that month.
The free limit is stated three ways. The homepage and FAQ promise free service for 9 or fewer people paid no more than once a month, the terms of service say 10 or fewer, and the fee schedule's per-posting charges start above 10 unique payees. Plan around 9 to be safe, and confirm your count with the company before signing up.
Scenario one, five employees, paid monthly, you file taxes: $0 for payroll, plus $15 a quarter for filled-in tax forms, $60 a year (our arithmetic). Paying twice a month adds the $15 unlimited batch posting fee, which the schedule lists without saying how often it recurs, so ask before switching to biweekly pay.
Scenario two, the same team on full service: the tax service at $350 a year plus direct deposit at the bundled $150 comes to $500 a year, or $600 on monthly billing (our arithmetic). The same five people cost $780 a year on Square Payroll, $840 on Wave Payroll, $948 on OnPay and $1,128 on Roll by ADP at list price.
Scenario three, twelve employees paid monthly on full service: crossing the free limit adds $10 per payroll posting, so the year comes to $620 with annual billing for the two services (our arithmetic). Square lists $1,284 a year for the same twelve people. Methodology: list prices only, one state, before trials and promotions; we did not run a Payroll4Free account for this review.
| Plan | Price | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Core payroll | $0 | Payroll runs, tax calculations, checks, own-bank direct deposit, PTO tracking, reports and employee portal for small teams paid once a month. |
| Payroll Tax Service | $35/mo or $350/yr | Payroll4Free deposits and files your payroll taxes for the first two tax authorities, including year-end W-2s. |
| Extra tax authority | $15/mo or $150/yr each | Each additional federal, state, local or other tax authority on the tax service. |
| Direct Deposit Service | $35/mo or $350/yr | Pay sent through Payroll4Free's bank; needs a reserve deposit sized to your largest seven-day payroll. |
| Direct deposit with tax service | $15/mo or $150/yr | The same direct deposit service at the bundled rate for tax service clients. |
| Filled-in tax forms | $15 per quarter | Completed payroll tax forms for owners who file themselves. |
| Payroll processing, 11 to 24 payees | $10 per posting | Applies to every payroll batch in a month with more unique payees than the free limit. |
| Payroll processing, 25+ payees | $35 per posting | Applies to every batch, for each increment of 25 unique payees in the month. |
| Staff setup or changes | $50 minimum | Bank setup, employee or tax changes, training or a custom check layout done by Payroll4Free staff. |
| Additional system user | $35 | An extra login to the payroll system. |
Payroll4Free pros and cons
What we like
- Payroll runs, tax calculations, checks and own-bank direct deposit cost $0 for small teams.
- Full service for five people costs $500 a year on annual billing, below every rival here.
- Pays W-2 employees and 1099 contractors on the same payroll.
What could be better
- The free limit reads 9 people on the homepage and 10 in the terms, and extra pay runs add fees.
- Direct deposit through its bank needs a reserve sized to your largest seven-day payroll.
Who Payroll4Free is for
Payroll4Free fits owners with a few employees, one state, monthly pay and the patience to file their own taxes. A small shop or practice in that position pays almost nothing, and our guide on how to run payroll yourself covers the deposit and filing steps you take on. Owners who want the filing done for them still pay far less than rivals for a five-person team, as long as they accept ads and a downloaded app.
Skip it if you pay weekly or biweekly, work across several states or want to run payroll from a phone. Each of those adds a fee or a friction point, and rivals like Square and OnPay include unlimited pay runs in one subscription. Our free payroll software and cheapest payroll software rankings compare the other low-cost routes, and the Patriot Payroll pricing breakdown covers the closest budget alternative.
Best Payroll4Free alternatives
If Payroll4Free is not the right fit, these are the closest options.
| Tool | Best for | Starts at | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Payroll4Free | Owners of very small teams, paid monthly in one state, who will file their own payroll taxes. | Free for small teams paid monthly | Visit → |
| Square Payroll | Square sellers and small teams that want full-service payroll with unlimited pay runs. | Free plan · Plus $49/mo · Premium $149/mo | Visit → |
| Wave Payroll | Owners who keep their books in Wave and want payroll in the same place. | Free plan · Pro $19/mo · Wave Advisors $149/mo · Wave Advisors (Starti | Visit → |
| OnPay | Small businesses that want full-service payroll with HR add-ons available later. | Partner $49/mo · custom-priced plans too | Visit → |
| Roll by ADP | Owners who want unlimited payroll runs from ADP at a flat per-employee price. | $59/mo plus $7 per employee | Visit → |
The bottom line
Payroll4Free is really free for a tiny, monthly, single-state payroll you file yourself, and still the cheapest full-service option here for about five people. The price is paid in other ways: ads, downloaded software, strict funding deadlines, a cash reserve for its direct deposit service and fees for extra runs or staff help. If those trade-offs fit, it saves several hundred dollars a year against the mainstream apps.
For the alternatives in depth, see our Square Payroll review, Wave Payroll review, OnPay review and Roll by ADP review, plus OnPay pricing and our breakdown of what payroll costs a small business.
Fees were checked on Payroll4Free's fee schedule and terms and on each rival's pricing page on November 4, 2026. Cite this: HRpresso, "Payroll4Free Review 2026: Is Free Payroll Really Free?", November 2026.
Frequently asked questions
Is Payroll4Free really free?
How does Payroll4Free make money?
How many employees can I pay for free?
Does Payroll4Free file payroll taxes?
Is Payroll4Free cheaper than Square Payroll or OnPay?
Some offers on this page may be paid placements or contain affiliate links.
More HRpresso reviews
Buyer guides and software reviews, with prices read from each vendor's own pricing page.
Browse all reviews