OnPay vs QuickBooks Payroll 2026: Flat $49 + $6 or Bundled Workforce Plans?
OnPay vs QuickBooks Payroll in 2026: OnPay is $49 a month plus $6 per worker; QuickBooks Workforce Payroll lists $50 plus $7 per employee. Costs at 5 to 50 staff.

OnPay is the cheaper payroll for most small businesses in 2026: $49 a month plus $6 per worker, with multi-state payroll and phone support included. QuickBooks' entry plan, Workforce Payroll, lists at $50 a month plus $7 per employee, so a 10-person team pays $11 more each month. QuickBooks earns its price when you want same-day direct deposit, an expert-built setup or IRS penalty cover.
The gap widens as you add HR and time tracking. OnPay sells them as add-ons with a bundle discount, while QuickBooks moves you to Workforce Premium at $88 a month plus $13 per employee, more than double OnPay's per-worker fee. For a team that already lives in QuickBooks Online, the bundle question is closer than it looks, and the numbers below settle it.
Prices were read on 4 November 2026 on OnPay's costs and pricing page and its direct deposit page, QuickBooks' payroll plans page, its payroll and accounting bundles and its QuickBooks Online pricing. QuickBooks was running a 50% discount for the first three months on every plan; this page uses the list prices you pay after it ends.
Toolradar data: Toolradar, the software directory we run, evaluates 78 payroll tools in its payroll ranking, and among its ten ranked picks the median cheapest paid plan is $19 a month as of October 2026. QuickBooks is listed as an alternative to 104 tools there, the most in the category, which is why it is the default comparison for OnPay and for Gusto.
At a glance
| Question | OnPay | QuickBooks Payroll | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry price | Payroll Essentials, $49/mo + $6/worker | Workforce Payroll, $50/mo + $7/employee | OnPay |
| Time tracking and HR | Add-ons, or a bundle from $70/mo + $10/worker | Workforce Premium, $88/mo + $13/employee | OnPay |
| Fastest direct deposit | A maximum 4-day turnaround, at no extra cost | Same-day on Premium and Elite; next-day on Payroll | QuickBooks |
| Setup help | Free setup and full data migration on every account | Expert review on Premium; expert-built setup on Elite | Tie, OnPay on price |
| Tax penalty protection | Accuracy guarantee on tax filings | Elite pays IRS penalties up to $25,000 a year | QuickBooks Elite |
| Accounting in the same bill | Integrates with QuickBooks Online and others | Bundles with Simple Start, Essentials or Plus | QuickBooks for one login |
| Introductory offer | First month free | 50% off for three months | Depends on team size |
How much do OnPay and QuickBooks Payroll cost?
| Plan | Base per month | Per worker per month | What it adds |
|---|---|---|---|
| OnPay Payroll Essentials | $49 | $6 | Full-service payroll, all states, onboarding, benefits admin, support |
| OnPay + HR + Time Tracking bundle | $70 | $10 | Time clocks, PTO approvals, onboarding workflows, org chart |
| QuickBooks Workforce Payroll | $50 | $7 | Full-service payroll, auto payroll, next-day direct deposit, 1099 e-file |
| QuickBooks Workforce Premium | $88 | $13 | Time tracking app, same-day direct deposit, hiring, HR workflows, setup review |
| QuickBooks Workforce Elite | $134 | $17 | Expert-built setup, IRS penalty protection up to $25,000 a year |
Sources: OnPay pricing and QuickBooks payroll plans, read 4 November 2026. QuickBooks list prices shown; its 50%-off-for-three-months offer is a limited-time discount.
OnPay has one payroll plan and prices everything else as an add-on. HR costs $15 a month plus $2 per worker, Time Tracking $15 plus $4, Compliance Resources $10 a month and Live HR Support $65 a month. The bundle for hourly teams combines payroll, time and HR at a discount of $9 on the base and $2 per worker.
QuickBooks works the other way: three fixed tiers, each with more built in. That suits a buyer who wants one decision, and costs more for a buyer who needs one feature from the higher tier.
What does each cost at 5, 10, 25 and 50 employees?
| Team size | OnPay Payroll Essentials | QuickBooks Workforce Payroll | OnPay payroll + HR + time bundle | QuickBooks Workforce Premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | $79/mo | $85/mo | $120/mo | $153/mo |
| 10 | $109/mo | $120/mo | $170/mo | $218/mo |
| 25 | $199/mo | $225/mo | $320/mo | $413/mo |
| 50 | $349/mo | $400/mo | $570/mo | $738/mo |
Our arithmetic on list prices, 4 November 2026: base plus per-worker fee times headcount, before any introductory discount.
On payroll alone, OnPay saves $1 a month plus $1 per worker. That is $132 a year at 10 people and $612 a year at 50, by our arithmetic. The difference is real but modest: a payroll-only buyer whose books already sit in QuickBooks Online may value one vendor more than that saving.
With time tracking and HR, the gap is much wider. At 25 employees, QuickBooks Workforce Premium costs $93 a month more than OnPay's payroll, HR and time bundle, or $1,116 a year. Premium does include items OnPay's bundle does not list, such as same-day direct deposit and an expert review of your setup, so the question is whether those are worth that premium.
Does the QuickBooks accounting bundle change the math?
QuickBooks sells payroll bundled with QuickBooks Online. Workforce Payroll plus Simple Start lists at $88 a month plus $6.50 per employee, and Workforce Payroll plus Essentials at $125 plus $6.50. Bought separately, Simple Start lists at $38 a month, so the bundle saves $0.50 per employee against buying the two pieces apart.
OnPay integrates with QuickBooks Online, so the fair comparison is OnPay plus Simple Start: $87 a month plus OnPay's per-worker fee, by our arithmetic. That combination beats the QuickBooks bundle by $1 a month plus $0.50 per worker, about $72 a year at 10 people. The bundle's advantage is one vendor and one login, not price.
For a payroll admin, that single login matters more than it sounds. QuickBooks Premium's time data flows into payroll and job costing inside the same product, while OnPay's general ledger sync posts after every pay run into the accounting tool you choose.
Where each one wins
Price and simplicity: OnPay
OnPay prints one plan with no hidden per-run fees: unlimited pay runs, W-2s and 1099s, federal, state and local filings and multi-state payroll are all in the $49 base. It also includes free account setup and historical data migration, and support by phone, chat and email from 9am to 8pm on weekdays.
The weakness is speed and depth. OnPay quotes a maximum 4-day turnaround for direct deposit, against same-day on QuickBooks' upper tiers, and its HR, time and compliance tools cost extra, so a 25-person hourly team that needs all of them pays the bundle rate, not the headline one.
Payday speed and expert help: QuickBooks
QuickBooks Workforce Premium and Elite offer same-day direct deposit when you run payroll by 7:00 am, and Workforce Payroll offers next-day deposit for payrolls run by 5:00 pm. Premium adds an expert review of your setup, and Elite has an expert build it for you.
Elite's headline is tax penalty protection: if you receive an IRS penalty, QuickBooks pays penalty fees and interest up to $25,000 a year and represents you. At $134 a month plus $17 per employee, that cover costs $2,628 a year for a 5-person team by our arithmetic, which only makes sense for a business that has already paid a penalty or runs complex payroll.
HR and hiring: QuickBooks Premium has more built in
Premium includes hiring and onboarding, recruiting with applicant tracking, automated I-9, time-off management, a company documents center and up to five automated HR workflows. OnPay's HR add-on covers PTO, onboarding workflows, an org chart and unlimited e-signature documents, and Live HR Support adds licensed HR experts for $65 a month.
A team that hires often gets more in QuickBooks' box, while a stable team that mainly needs PTO tracking pays far less for OnPay's add-on.
Benefits: close
Both connect health insurance, 401(k) and workers' comp. OnPay includes benefits administration and guidance from licensed in-house agents, and you pay plan premiums only. QuickBooks offers health packages by Allstate and 401(k) plans by Vestwell, and lists benefits administration on Premium as limited in availability with additional fees.
Who should pick which
| If you are | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A 1 to 50 person team that just needs payroll | OnPay | Cheaper at every headcount, all states included |
| An hourly team needing time clocks and PTO | OnPay bundle | Far cheaper than Workforce Premium at every size |
| A team that pays on short notice | QuickBooks Premium | Same-day direct deposit |
| An owner who wants payroll set up for them and penalty cover | QuickBooks Elite | Expert setup, up to $25,000 a year of IRS penalty cover |
| A business that wants books and payroll in one login | QuickBooks bundle | One vendor, close to OnPay plus Simple Start on price |
How we compared
We read OnPay's pricing page, QuickBooks' payroll plans, bundles and QuickBooks Online pricing on 4 November 2026. Monthly totals are our arithmetic on list prices, excluding QuickBooks' three-month discount, OnPay's free first month, state taxes and benefits premiums. Features are as each vendor describes them on those pages. For the longer views, see the OnPay pricing breakdown, the OnPay review and the QuickBooks Payroll review.
FAQ
Is OnPay cheaper than QuickBooks Payroll?
Yes. OnPay costs $49 a month plus $6 per worker, and QuickBooks Workforce Payroll lists at $50 a month plus $7 per employee, so OnPay saves $1 a month plus $1 per worker. At 10 employees that is $109 against $120 a month on list prices.
Does QuickBooks Payroll have a discount right now?
QuickBooks was offering 50% off for the first three months on its payroll plans when we checked on 4 November 2026, so Workforce Payroll started at $25 a month plus $7 per employee. After three months the list price applies. OnPay offers the first month free.
Which offers same-day direct deposit?
QuickBooks Workforce Premium and Elite offer same-day direct deposit for payrolls run by 7:00 am, and Workforce Payroll offers next-day deposit. OnPay quotes a maximum 4-day turnaround for direct deposit, so a business that approves payroll late in the cycle should plan around that lead time.
Should I buy the QuickBooks payroll and accounting bundle?
Only if one login matters to you. Workforce Payroll plus Simple Start lists at $88 a month plus $6.50 per employee, while OnPay plus a separate Simple Start subscription comes out slightly cheaper at every team size, by our arithmetic. OnPay integrates with QuickBooks Online and syncs the general ledger after every pay run.
Does OnPay charge for multi-state payroll?
No. OnPay includes payroll in all 50 states at no additional cost, with automatic state tax registrations and local withholding calculations. That makes it a strong fit for remote teams spread across several states.
Which is better for a growing team that hires often?
QuickBooks Workforce Premium includes recruiting with applicant tracking, automated I-9, hiring and onboarding and HR workflows, at $88 a month plus $13 per employee. OnPay's HR add-on is cheaper but lighter, so frequent hirers get more from Premium.
Cite this: HRpresso, "OnPay vs QuickBooks Payroll 2026: Flat $49 + $6 or Bundled Workforce Plans?", November 2026.
For related comparisons, read Gusto vs OnPay, Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll, Gusto pricing, the cheapest payroll software, the best payroll software, the best free payroll software, the Gusto review and the best payroll software for small business.
Some offers on this page may be paid placements or contain affiliate links.
More HRpresso reviews
Buyer guides and software reviews, with prices read from each vendor's own pricing page.
Browse all reviews