Guide

SurePayroll Pricing 2026: Full Service vs No Tax Filing per Employee

SurePayroll Full Service is $29/mo plus $7 per employee and No Tax Filing $20 plus $4 in 2026: costs at 1 to 20 employees, year-end fees, promo.

SurePayroll Pricing 2026: Full Service vs No Tax Filing per Employee

SurePayroll costs $29 a month plus $7 per employee on Full Service, which files and deposits your payroll taxes, and $20 a month plus $4 per employee on No Tax Filing, where you file and deposit them yourself. Both are billed monthly with unlimited payroll runs and no contract, and year-end W-2 and 1099-NEC forms cost extra. Prices read on SurePayroll's pricing page and its small business plans page on November 4, 2026.

Our view: for most employers the real decision is whether $9 a month plus $3 per employee is worth handing off tax deposits and filings. At five employees that handoff costs $288 a year, which is cheap insurance against a missed deposit, so Full Service is the default and No Tax Filing suits owners who already run their own filings or have an accountant doing them.

Toolradar data: of the 78 payroll tools Toolradar tracks as of November 4, 2026, the median entry paid plan with a flat monthly fee is $25 (31 tools), according to its payroll statistics. SurePayroll's No Tax Filing base sits under that median and its Full Service base just above it. Toolradar is the software directory we run.

SurePayroll plans at a glance

Plan Monthly base Per employee Payroll taxes What it includes
Full Service $29 $7 Filed and deposited by SurePayroll Unlimited payroll runs, free 2-day direct deposit, automatic scheduling, W-2 employees and 1099 contractors, new hire reporting, online pay stubs, mobile app
No Tax Filing $20 $4 You file and deposit them The Full Service features except tax filing and deposits
Nanny and Household $39 (marked down from $45) One employee included Filed and deposited, Schedule H prepared State tax ID registration help, W-2 and Schedule H forms, unlimited runs

Prices are monthly in USD from SurePayroll's pricing and small business pages, November 4, 2026, billed monthly with cancellation at any time. The first state is included, and payroll in more states costs extra. Some visitors see a higher lineup on SurePayroll's site, with $39 and $29 base fees and the same per-employee rates; the figures here match the pricing calculator on its pricing page.

SurePayroll is the small business payroll brand of Paychex, as its about page says. For a buyer the parent matters less than the fee structure: a flat base plus a per-employee rate, with no tiers to climb. If you are also looking at Gusto, our Gusto pricing breakdown runs the same headcount math on its plans.

How much does SurePayroll cost per month?

HRpresso data: we priced both plans at five team sizes from the list rates read on November 4, 2026. Each monthly figure is the base fee plus the per-employee fee times headcount, for one state, before the promotion, year-end forms and add-ons.

Employees Full Service No Tax Filing Monthly gap Yearly gap
1 $36 $24 $12 $144
3 $50 $32 $18 $216
5 $64 $40 $24 $288
10 $99 $60 $39 $468
20 $169 $100 $69 $828

The gap grows by $3 for every person you add, because the per-employee fees differ as well as the base. A solo owner pays $144 a year to have taxes handled, and a 20-person company pays $828. At that size it is worth pricing a payroll accountant against the Full Service gap, though for most small teams the plan is still the cheaper handoff.

Per-employee pricing also means every hire lifts the Full Service bill by the same $7, with no tier jump. A company growing from 5 to 10 people sees its bill go from $64 to $99, a predictable climb that is easy to budget against headcount plans.

What the first year costs with the November promotion

SurePayroll runs a "Six Months Free Payroll Over One Year" promotion from November 1 to November 30, 2026, per its terms and conditions. An eligible new client gets the base and per-employee fees credited in months 1, 3, 5, 7, 9 and 11 after the account opens, which is the "free alternate months" offer on the pricing page.

Full Service, one state 5 employees 10 employees
12 months at list price $768 $1,188
Year-end forms (W-2s only) $75 $100
First year at list price $843 $1,288
First year with the promotion $459 $694

Our arithmetic on SurePayroll's list rates, November 4, 2026. The promotion covers only the monthly base and per-employee fees; year-end fees, multi-state filing, accounting integrations and one-time exception requests are still billed.

The fine print is a 12-month commitment in practice. To stay eligible you must keep an active account for 12 consecutive months, you cannot have run payroll with SurePayroll in the prior 90 days, household employers have their own version of the offer, and an unused free month has no cash value. A business that might switch providers within the year should value the promotion at less than its face amount.

What does SurePayroll charge on top of the plan?

Extra Price When you pay it
Year-end W-2 and 1099-NEC forms $50 base + $5 per form Billed annually, not monthly
Multi-state payroll $9.99/mo From the second state
Local taxes Separate fee, amount not shown on the pricing page Areas that levy local payroll taxes
Accounting software integration $4.99/mo Syncing payroll to your books
Timeclock integration From $5/mo + $3 per employee Importing hours automatically
Employment law support Plans from $30/mo Legal and HR compliance help
401(k) plans Custom quote Retirement plan for staff

Prices from SurePayroll's pricing page, November 4, 2026.

The year-end charge is the line most quotes leave out. A 10-employee company that issues 10 W-2s pays $100 at year end, and a business paying 8 employees and 4 contractors pays $110 for 12 forms. Over a year that adds about $8 a month to the 10-person bill, small but worth including when you compare SurePayroll with providers that fold year-end forms into the plan price.

The local tax fee is the one to ask about before signing. If you have staff in a city or county with its own payroll tax, get the amount in writing, because the pricing calculator adds it as a separate line with no figure attached.

Full Service or No Tax Filing: which SurePayroll plan fits?

Choose Full Service if nobody on your team already handles federal and state payroll tax deposits. The plan calculates, files and deposits them, so the deposit calendar becomes SurePayroll's job instead of a recurring task on your list. Our guide to payroll tax rates in 2026 shows how many separate taxes a small employer has to deposit.

Choose No Tax Filing only if you or your accountant will file and deposit every payroll tax on time, for example because the accountant already files your other business taxes. It keeps direct deposit, pay stubs and unlimited runs, and at 10 employees it saves $468 a year. Read how to run payroll yourself first to see what that work involves each quarter.

Families paying a nanny or caregiver should look at the household plan instead. It includes one employee in the monthly price and prepares a signature-ready Schedule H at year end. Our best nanny payroll services guide compares it with the other household options.

Is SurePayroll cheaper than other payroll software?

SurePayroll's modest base fee works in its favor at one to three employees, when the per-employee charge is still a small share of the bill. As headcount grows the per-employee fee dominates, and the year-end form charge widens the gap against providers that include forms in the plan price.

Our SurePayroll review prices it against named competitors at each team size, and the cheapest payroll software ranking lines up the lowest-cost plans across the market. If you are weighing it against its parent company's own plans, start with cheaper Paychex alternatives and the Paychex review. For a bigger picture of the full cost of payroll, including taxes and benefits, see how much payroll costs for a small business.

How we built this page

We read SurePayroll's pricing page, its small business plans page, its about page and the terms of its current promotion on November 4, 2026. The category figure comes from Toolradar's payroll statistics computed the same day. Every monthly, yearly and first-year figure is our arithmetic on published list rates, for one state and before add-ons unless stated. We did not open a SurePayroll account for this page. Related pricing breakdowns: OnPay pricing and Patriot Payroll pricing.

FAQ

How much does SurePayroll cost in 2026?

SurePayroll Full Service costs $29 a month plus $7 per employee, and No Tax Filing costs $20 a month plus $4 per employee, both billed monthly with no contract, as listed on SurePayroll's pricing page on November 4, 2026. Year-end W-2 and 1099-NEC forms are billed once a year on top, and a second state adds a monthly fee.

What is the difference between SurePayroll Full Service and No Tax Filing?

Full Service calculates, files and deposits your federal and state payroll taxes. No Tax Filing keeps the same payroll features, including direct deposit and unlimited runs, but leaves every tax filing and deposit to you. The price gap is $9 a month plus $3 per employee, so a 5-person company pays $288 a year more for Full Service.

Does SurePayroll charge for W-2s?

Yes. SurePayroll bills year-end W-2 and 1099-NEC forms annually at a base fee plus a fee per form. A company issuing 10 W-2s pays $100 at year end, which the six-free-months promotion does not cover.

Does SurePayroll have a free trial or free months?

There is no standing free plan, but new small business and household clients who sign up between November 1 and November 30, 2026 get the monthly plan fees credited in six alternating months of their first year. The credit requires 12 consecutive months of active service and does not apply to year-end, multi-state or integration fees.

How much is SurePayroll for one employee?

A one-employee business pays $36 a month on Full Service or $24 on No Tax Filing, by our arithmetic on the list rates. A household employer paying a nanny uses the separate household plan, which is $39 a month with one employee included and prepares Schedule H.

Cite this: HRpresso, "SurePayroll Pricing 2026: Full Service vs No Tax Filing per Employee", November 2026.

Some offers on this page may be paid placements or contain affiliate links.

More HRpresso reviews

Buyer guides and software reviews, with prices read from each vendor's own pricing page.

Browse all reviews